If I Ask For Whiskey On My Deathbed Please Just Give It To Me

Alcohol is no longer part of my life. I don’t miss it, and I have no intention of ever touching the stuff again. When I left Thamkrabok temple almost 6 years ago I was convinced my addiction had ended, and I still feel exactly the same way today. Some might say that I’m being overly confident, but it is just the way I feel.

The Founder of Alcoholics Anonymous Asked for Whiskey on His Death Bed

In the biography My Name Is Bill Susan Cheever reveals how the founder of Alcoholics Anonymous asked for alcohol shortly before his death. At the time he was losing his battle against chronic emphysema and only had days to live. It is reported the he asked for whisky on four separate occasions, but it was never given to him. It appears that protecting the legacy of the man who founded Alcoholics Anonymous was more important than comfort during his last hours. Bill Wilson’s requests for whiskey were recorded in the notes by the nurse taking care of him.

I personally find it a bit deplorable that Bill W. was not given alcohol when he requested it. I have experience working as a nurse in palliative care, and I have seen how tough the process of dying can be. People can be terrified so anything that can give them some comfort is welcome. The only reason that I can see why Bill W. was denied his dying request was an attempt to protect his image and the image of the program he created. These are not good justifications in my mind. He had already made it to the end of his life so what difference did it make if he drank again? It wasn’t like he was going to go on a drunken rampage or damage his liver. It just bothers me that this man who had helped so many was denied some final comfort and for what?

If I Ask For Whiskey on My Deathbed Please Give It to Me

I have no plans to ask for whiskey on my deathbed, but if I do it should be given to me. I intend to leave this world completely sober because I want to fully observe the process – even if it is only blinking out into nothingness. The reality is though, that we have no idea how we are going to react to dying until we are facing it. Ram Dass talks about this in the documentary Fierce Grace . He devoted decades to spiritual training but he still felt overwhelmed when faced with own death – this was when he was having his stroke. Dying is not an easy thing.

Latest posts by Paul Garrigan (see all)

11 thoughts on “If I Ask For Whiskey On My Deathbed Please Just Give It To Me

    1. Hi Lynne, it is a bit sad. I wouldn’t have thought any less of him for drinking on his death bed. Dying can be a tough business and we don’t know how we are going to react until it happens.

      1. That article and most likely the book is misleading. Bill Wilson’s emphysema had periodically deprived his brain cells of oxygen. He was on numerous meds when on his deathbed. The phenomenon of craving alcohol is normal for alcoholics, especially those in Wilson’s state of mind. With over 2 million active members, AA’s numbers speak well of it’s successful approach in dealing with the disease of alcolholism. Did any legitimate critic give this book a positive review?

        1. Hi Mike, I’m not swayed much by your argument that Bill asked for whiskey because of his emphysema. I understand why you might feel that his image needs protecting, but it is a bit of a leap. I could be wrong but when people are so hypoxic that affects their judgment they struggle to even manage sips of water. Do you also believe that his emphysema is the reason for why he took LSD during the sixties?

          This book was written by an AA member, and the portrayal is generally flattering. Some AA members seem to have liked the book, and some didn’t – you can do the research for yourself if you’re interested. I have no idea what you mean by ‘legitimate critic’ – do you mean critics that believe what you believe?

          I greatly Bill W. and I don’t believe that his desire for whiskey on his deathbed says much about the effectiveness of AA. He was a fallible human being just like everyone else.

  1. Paul, I think the point you document about Bill Wilson’s death bed request shows that for many people the fight against alcohol addiction is a lifelong battle. It’s a very interesting story and like Lynne one I’d never heard before.

    I’d have given him the bottle and asked if he wanted a cigarette as well.
    Martyn recently posted..Best Bars in Udon Thani – Up2u Bar

  2. What you read in print and what actually happened are sometimes 2 different things ,Wilson may have had whisky who knows

  3. I think there are a few things you’re missing, Paul. Maybe this is just one of those knee-jerk, online articles that aren’t really thought out. Maybe you really thought about it, and these are the conclusions you’ve made. Regardless, you certainly seem absolute in your thinking that the nurse should’ve given Bill whiskey.

    First, is your assertion that “It appears that protecting the legacy of the man who founded Alcoholics Anonymous was more important than comfort during his last hours.”
    She was a nurse. Perhaps she knew a little something about the Hippocratic Oath. Dying of emphysema is a messy affair. It’s a terrible way to die. What would alcohol have done to him in last days?

    You claim that it would have comforted him. How do you know that? Because he asked for it? Hell, if alcohol would’ve comforted him in his dying days, imagine the joy he would’ve experienced had she shot him up with an 8-ball of coke, invited a couple of hookers into the room, and slipped him a tab of acid!

    No. Bill was an alcoholic. Maybe he was in a state of delusion. Maybe he wasn’t. But he definitely knew that it was a progressive disease. Perhaps the nurse knew that too, and I bet she knew that you don’t give a man whiskey on his death bed and call it “comfort care”.

  4. Great article, Paul. I think flashes of spiritual insight are enormously difficult to convey, which is why organised religion can do so much harm as well as good. Personally I think AA is a little bit like organised religion in that respect.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge